B’midbar
Numbers 1:1 – 4:20
“Too big to fail.” This pithy phrase seems to have become the mantra of American business life as magnates and politicians stoke the public’s fear of financial disaster if this company goes under, or that country doesn’t honor our trade agreements. Failure is not an option, we are told, and so our elected representatives pour more capital into them—not only to keep them “big” but to help them grow unsustainably ever bigger. But if they were “too big to fail” yesterday, what will they be tomorrow?
Our sages believe that whatever is happening on the outside is but a reflection of what is taking place on the inside; our outer world is a reflection of our inner world. We Americans seem to have a deeply ingrained fear of failure, and often that fear is manifested in our nation’s policies and politics. To be sure, most (if not all) societies have certain norms to which “normal” people are expected to adhere. Growing up in France, for instance, I learned early on that the worst faux pas was to be perceived as an idiot, an uneducated ignoramus. In Israel, to be a freier, someone easily taken advantage of, is to invite social ostracism. In the U.S., the fatal flaw that will get you excluded from social circles is to be a “loser.” No failing allowed. The ego, which has internalized this message since early childhood, protects itself from being a “loser” by surrounding itself with “more” and “better” and “more powerful” stuff to prove to itself and to other egos that it is not a failure. Perhaps, in a society where narcissism is rampant, we have built up our egos so much that they too have become too big to fail. We feed them with addictions of all sorts, bail them out over and over again with all kinds of “feel good” potions, and try to control every little thing that could affect their fragile sense of well-being. Rabbi Rami Shapiro wrote an entire book demonstrating that we are addicted to control. How else are we going to protect ourselves from failure? Strengthening our ego is our only option—but that is not sustainable either.
True spirituality offers us a different pathway if we are courageous enough to take it. It is the pathway alluded to in the name of this week’s Torah portion: B’midbar—In the desert. In the desert there is nothing: nothing to hide behind, nothing to own, nothing to lose, and nothing to pretend to be. In the vastness of the desert, we encounter the smallness of our being; we break through the illusions and the mirages to realize our powerlessness and lack of control. In the desert we are naked, stripped bare of our stories, our ideas, our views, our knowledge, our reasons, our justifications. In the desert there is no success and no failure, no winner and no loser—and no fear of being a loser. In the desert there is silence. It is not a mistake that the Hebrew word for desert—midbar—shares the same root as the word medaber, meaning “that which speaks.” Only in the silence of the midbar are we able to hear That which speaks. Only after letting go of the clutter, shedding the nonessential, turning off the noise of the ever-racing ego mind, are we able to hear the still small voice within the heart that has never stopped whispering “V’ahavta!—Love!”
So take the road less traveled, the one that leads forward to the yet uncovered midbar of the soul. It is the road of deepening meditation, the road of contemplation, the place where you find the silence in your life. Embark on a journey toward a simpler, more loving, more giving and forgiving, more compassionate way of life. Journey to the midbar, to that space where the ego is gently allowed to fail so that the heart can heal and open itself to true freedom.
PS: Once a year I come to you with a simple ask: if you enjoy reading these freely offered Torah Reflections (almost) every week, please consider making a donation to support Bet Alef, the organization that allows me to do this sacred work week-in and week-out.
If you are reading this on your computer or iPad, please click on this link to be directed to the Bet Alef website’s donation page. On the right side of your screen type in the amount you wish to donate and click “select fund.” Under “Education,” please choose “adult learning.”
If you are reading this on the Bet Alef app, tap the menu icon (top left corner,) choose “giving,” and follow the prompts.